About Us

iceandfire explores human rights stories through performance.

High quality production is supported by innovative education, outreach and participation.

Read more about our background here »

 

Donate

Blog

Individual vs Society’s Rights

There is an ad on television at the moment that really gets my goat. I have a cold shiver every time it’s on. No, it’s not the Go Compare opera man, it’s an ad for skincare that starts with the line “Your skin has 3 fundamental rights…”

Skin doesn’t have rights, and I find the notion offensive. “The right to moisturisation”? Puh-lease!

Although this is just a small, trivial example, I think this ad (I can’t even remember what the product is, so it fails on that level too!) represents a wider problem, where the Human Rights Act, and the broader concept of human rights, is trivialised and misunderstood. A right is different to a want. And rights often come with responsibilities.

Afua Hirsch has an excellent regular column in the Guardian, Human Rights Watch. She also writes, along with Henry Porter, the Liberty Central Blog. In a blog post last week, Hirsch writes:

“… in England, the Human Rights act is unloved. There is a view – largely based on misunderstanding, in my opinion, but I’m a lawyer so I’m told I don’t count that the human rights act is a villain’s charter. It is accused of protecting criminals and thugs, and all the while failing to protect the law-abiding public from more important developments, like the spread of surveillance.”

Hirsch goes on to say that in Northern Ireland and Scotland they have differing approaches and attitudes to the Human Rights Act. In NI especially, perhaps because events that have violated people’s rights and scared the public are so recent, they are pushing for their own Bill of Rights that goes further than the current one, “whether the law should protect the right to housing, work and education – socio-economic rights that are barely even discussed in Great Britain.”

But not only is the Human Rights Act undermined by people claiming that it focuses on protecting “the bad guys”, as Hirsch mentions above, but it is also undermined by people who misuse it – either in name or in practice. The number of times you hear someone claim “But it’s my right to… drink more even though I’m inebriated/talk loudly at the cinema and annoy other patrons/take up two seats on the bus…”.

“It’s a free country.”

Why does the concept of rights and freedom get associated with selfishness and individual wants over and above what society needs? It’s offensive to those people who genuinely don’t have their human rights, who don’t have the freedom to make ridiculous, generalised complaints about “rights infringements”.

Human rights walks the fine line between an individual’s needs and what society requires to function and provide for its citizens. You may have the right to do whatever you want to your own body – like continue drinking even when you’re drunk, for eg – but what if that makes you violent towards someone else? Or you end up in hospital, and taxpayers have to foot the bill? Rights and responsibilities go hand in hand and should not be used and abused for trivial, petty wants.

Skin doesn’t have rights. But we all have a responsibility to challenge the misuse of such an important concept.

By Charlotte George, Media & Communications Officer

Comments (0)

Comments

Leave a comment

(*required)

(will not be published) (*required)

Upcoming Events

May 2012
M T W T F S S
« Apr   Jun »
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031  

Recent Posts

  • Asylum Dialogues – Hull

    @ 4.30pm – Middleton Hall, Hull University, Hull. This is a CoS and Co-op joint event


    Posted on 9/19/2012
  • Palestine Monologues – London

    To know more about Al Madad Foundation click here


    Posted on 7/18/2012
  • Palestine Monologues – Hitchin

    in collaboration with Hitchin Amnesty group. More details soon.


    Posted on 7/12/2012
  • Asylum Dialogues – Huddersfield

    @ 5pm – Huddersfield New College. This is a Co-op and CoS partnership event.


    Posted on 7/4/2012
  • On a Clear Day You Can See Dover – Huddersfield

    Performance and workshop with Hudds New College students.


    Posted on 7/3/2012
  • Asylum Monologues – Nottingham

    @7.45pm -  St John’s Church, Carrington, Nottingham. Q&A session will follow the peformance.


    Posted on 6/28/2012
  • Asylum Dialogues/Illegals – Ipswich

    at Ipswich Town Hall, organised by City of Sactuary. The performance is part of “Sanctuary Sunday” which runs from 3pm until 6pm. The event is part of Refugee Week. Fore more info and booking click here


    Posted on 6/24/2012
  • Asylum Monologues – Glasgow

    @ 6pm – Tron Theatre, Glasgow. As part of Refugee Week. Book now your FREE ticket calling 0141 552 4267 For directions click here


    Posted on 6/22/2012
  • Asylum Monologues – Great Torrington

    @ 7.30pm - The Plough Arts Centre, 9-11 Fore Street Torrington, Devon This event is produced and performed by The Plough Arts Centre Tickets are £3 or FREE for refugees, asylum seekers and unwaged. The proceeds from the event will go to North Devon Sunrise Group.


    Posted on 6/21/2012
  • Asylum Dialogues – Leeds

    @12 noon – as part of Valuing Diversity event, organised by Co-op and CoS.


    Posted on 6/18/2012

Recent Comments

  • Craig Siddons: Being made redundant from my last three positions, I have struggled this last time to find work, as a...
  • Olwen Thomas: Lots of love and god wishes for the future, Clea. I will miss working with you and your never –...
  • Olwen Thomas: Lots of love and good wishes, Clea. It has been a very great pleasure working with you and being...
  • Derek Paget: Good luck for the future, Clea – and especially with that event at the end of the month!
  • Jeannette Josse: Beautifully written piece Sonja. You highlight how politics, oppression etc can disrupt the...